Skip to content
Lions of ZionEvidence, not narratives

Ask the desk

A question answered across what this desk has published. Not a search box: Search finds a record, this reads them. Where there is no evidence, the answer says so.

Ask about anything this desk has published, or the claims behind it.

Suggested questions

Search

Search

Find a published record. For a question answered across them, ask the desk.

Support Us

Narrative WatchInternational media

Reported claim: the Venice documentary "NAZA" shows Israel used AI to kill Gaza civilians by design

"NAZA", by Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor, won Venice's Special Jury Prize on September 12, 2026. It rests on 24 anonymous Israeli military and intelligence interviewees who describe AI-assisted target selection and rising permitted civilian-casualty thresholds. The IDF "categorically rejects" the allegations. What is documented, what is asserted and what cannot be checked are set out below.

Narrative Watch

Claim record

DisputedThe claim

Israel's military used an AI system ('Lavender') to select tens of thousands of targets in Gaza and, as a matter of policy, knowingly killed civilians in their homes on a mass scale — killing 'by design', as shown by 24 anonymous Israeli soldiers and intelligence officers interviewed in the documentary NAZA.

The finding

Credible sources disagree and the record does not settle it.

Evidence basis
Cited public sources
Trend
Spreading further
Observed propagators
The film's producers and festival campaign (The Guardian, JW Films, directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor), RT (Russian state media), Al Jazeera English, Activist and conspiracy sites (Daily Kos, The People's Voice), Social-media accounts citing a '70,000 targets' figure
Arenas
Venice Film Festival press, International press and reviews, X (Twitter), Instagram, TikTok, Israeli public debate
Israeli position
The IDF 'categorically rejects' the allegations, says anonymous testimonies cannot be verified, that junior soldiers lack knowledge of national strategy, and that strike selection and approval were made by human personnel only, not AI; it rejects any policy to kill tens of thousands in their homes. Former PM Naftali Bennett called the film a 'blood libel'. No Foreign Ministry statement found as of September 13, 2026.
Security context
Released during the 2026 US–Israel–Iran war and with the Gaza campaign's conduct under international legal scrutiny; the film covers 2023–2025 events and extends a 2024 +972/Local Call/Guardian investigation from six to 24 anonymous sources.
Editorial illustration: an empty cinema auditorium, the screen showing a night aerial view of a dense city block overlaid with a military targeting interface of selection boxes, crosshairs and telemetry readouts.
Editorial illustration, not documentary evidenceEditorial illustration of the claim this record assesses. It is not a targeting screen, not footage from the documentary, and not evidence of any strike; the interface, the coordinates and the city are invented for the illustration.
Image credit and provenance
Lions of ZionRights cleared · Generated in-house

Follow the evidence

From claim to record

Each stage is a reading path through this published investigation.

The claim being examined

Israel's military used an AI system ('Lavender') to select tens of thousands of targets in Gaza and, as a matter of policy, knowingly killed civilians in their homes on a mass scale — killing 'by design', as shown by 24 anonymous Israeli soldiers and intelligence officers interviewed in the documentary NAZA.

  1. Claim

    The claim being examined

    Israel's military used an AI system ('Lavender') to select tens of thousands of targets in Gaza and, as a matter of policy, knowingly killed civilians in their homes on a mass scale — killing 'by design', as shown by 24 anonymous Israeli soldiers and intelligence officers interviewed in the documentary NAZA.

  2. Origin

    Public record cited by this article

    These are the public materials the published record links to. Open them to inspect the original reporting.

    1. Israeli-made Gaza documentary wins at Venice festivalRTÉ (AFP/Reuters) · 12 Sept 2026
    2. IDF rejects testimonies in Israeli-made documentary about AI-powered killing in GazaThe Times of Israel · 11 Sept 2026
    3. Israelis' film alleging AI-assisted killing of Gaza civilians wins Venice jury prizeThe Times of Israel · 11 Sept 2026
    4. Israeli film on Gaza receives 25-minute ovation at Venice premiereAl Jazeera · 10 Sept 2026
    5. 'NAZA' Review: Doc Accuses Israel Of Using AI To Kill Gaza CiviliansDeadline · 10 Sept 2026
    6. Former Israeli Prime Minister Takes Aim At Yuval Abraham And Rachel Szor's 'NAZA'Deadline · 10 Sept 2026
    7. Israel used AI to kill thousands of Palestinians in Gaza – documentary (propagator example, not a source of fact)RT · 10 Sept 2026
    8. Documentary alleging Israel committed wanton killing in Gaza gets standing ovation in VeniceJewish Telegraphic Agency · 9 Sept 2026
    9. 'NAZA' documentary premieres in Venice with Gaza war claimsThe Jerusalem Post · 9 Sept 2026
    10. 'NAZA' Venice Premiere: Gaza Documentary Earns Record Standing OvationVariety · 9 Sept 2026
    11. Israeli film about killing of Gazan civilians gets 25-minute record ovation at Venice premiereThe Times of Israel · 9 Sept 2026
    12. 'Lavender': The AI machine directing Israel's bombing spree in Gaza+972 Magazine · 2 Apr 2024
  3. Observed spread

    What the record observes

    These named propagators are recorded in the article. This does not by itself establish coordination or affiliation.

    • The film's producers and festival campaign (The Guardian, JW Films, directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor)
    • RT (Russian state media)
    • Al Jazeera English
    • Activist and conspiracy sites (Daily Kos, The People's Voice)
    • Social-media accounts citing a '70,000 targets' figure
  4. Evidence

    What the sources support

    The article cites these materials as its public evidence. It does not represent reposting or citation alone as proof of coordination.

    1. Israeli-made Gaza documentary wins at Venice festivalRTÉ (AFP/Reuters) · 12 Sept 2026
    2. IDF rejects testimonies in Israeli-made documentary about AI-powered killing in GazaThe Times of Israel · 11 Sept 2026
    3. Israelis' film alleging AI-assisted killing of Gaza civilians wins Venice jury prizeThe Times of Israel · 11 Sept 2026
    4. Israeli film on Gaza receives 25-minute ovation at Venice premiereAl Jazeera · 10 Sept 2026
    5. 'NAZA' Review: Doc Accuses Israel Of Using AI To Kill Gaza CiviliansDeadline · 10 Sept 2026
    6. Former Israeli Prime Minister Takes Aim At Yuval Abraham And Rachel Szor's 'NAZA'Deadline · 10 Sept 2026
    7. Israel used AI to kill thousands of Palestinians in Gaza – documentary (propagator example, not a source of fact)RT · 10 Sept 2026
    8. Documentary alleging Israel committed wanton killing in Gaza gets standing ovation in VeniceJewish Telegraphic Agency · 9 Sept 2026
    9. 'NAZA' documentary premieres in Venice with Gaza war claimsThe Jerusalem Post · 9 Sept 2026
    10. 'NAZA' Venice Premiere: Gaza Documentary Earns Record Standing OvationVariety · 9 Sept 2026
    11. Israeli film about killing of Gazan civilians gets 25-minute record ovation at Venice premiereThe Times of Israel · 9 Sept 2026
    12. 'Lavender': The AI machine directing Israel's bombing spree in Gaza+972 Magazine · 2 Apr 2024
  5. Finding

    Disputed

    Credible sources disagree and the record does not settle it.

  6. Limitations

    What remains unresolved

    The record keeps these limits visible rather than converting them into certainty.

    • Identities, ranks, units and service dates of the 24 interviewees
    • Whether the described collateral-damage thresholds were written policy, unit practice or recollection
    • The origin of the '70,000 targets' figure circulating online (the 2024 investigation reported 37,000)
    • Whether any document or order shown in the film can be authenticated
    • Whether the Military Advocate General has examined the specific allegations
    • Whether the film will be released in Israel
  7. Recognition lesson

    How to read a claim responsibly

    Trace a claim to its origin, check whether sources are independent, and distinguish a citation, repost, affiliation and demonstrated coordination.

What is established. "NAZA" is an 80-minute documentary directed by the Israeli filmmakers Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor, who won the 2025 Academy Award for "No Other Land". It premiered in the main competition of the 83rd Venice International Film Festival on September 10, 2026, and received a standing ovation that festival reporters timed at about 25 minutes. On September 12, 2026, the festival jury gave it the Special Jury Prize. The film is a British production made by The Guardian and James Wilson's JW Films, with Jonathan Glazer as executive producer; international sales are handled by MK2 Films, and screenings are scheduled for San Sebastián (September 18–26) and the New York Film Festival (September 25–October 12). The title is the IDF's Hebrew shorthand for "nezek agavi", collateral damage: the number of civilians a planner expects an airstrike to kill.

What the film claims. According to the filmmakers and the reviews published from Venice (Deadline, Variety, The Hollywood Reporter, Screen), the film is built on interviews with 24 Israeli soldiers and intelligence officers who spoke on condition of anonymity. They describe an AI-assisted targeting system, referred to as "Lavender", that drew on Gaza's monitored telecommunications to generate suspected-militant targets; permitted civilian-casualty thresholds per target that, the interviewees say, rose over the war until "20 becomes the norm" for a low-level suspect; strikes on family homes authorised with those expected casualties; and shootings in designated no-go zones near aid distribution sites. The directors say the mass killing was "systemic: not by accident, but by design". Reuters quoted one interviewee describing a phrase like "daddy's home" detected on a child's phone as sufficient to trigger a strike. These are the film's claims, carried by anonymous testimony; this desk has not seen the underlying interviews and cannot verify the identities, ranks, units or dates the interviewees cover.

What is documented from before the film. In April 2024 Abraham published, in +972 Magazine and Local Call with The Guardian, an investigation based on six anonymous intelligence sources describing "Lavender" and reporting that the system had marked some 37,000 Palestinians as suspected militants. The IDF's response at the time, quoted by JTA and The Guardian, said its analysts use information systems as tools, that it does not use an AI system that identifies operatives or predicts whether a person is a terrorist, that it assesses "expected military advantage and likely collateral damage" before every strike, and that it rejected "any policy to kill tens of thousands of people in their homes". The film extends that 2024 reporting from six sources to 24 and adds the collateral-damage thresholds and the aid-site zones. The Times of Israel notes that parts of the earlier reporting "have been challenged by the Israel Defense Forces".

The response. On September 11–12, 2026, the IDF said it "categorically rejects" the allegations, criticised the use of anonymous testimonies whose identities "cannot be verified", said claims about "national and military strategy" exceed what junior soldiers can know, and stated that "the selection and approval of Gaza strikes [were] made by human personnel only … and not by artificial intelligence". It repeated that it "tried to avoid killing civilians" and that Hamas embedded its operatives and infrastructure among the civilian population, and it rejects all accusations of genocide. Former prime minister Naftali Bennett called the film "a horrific blood libel against our sons and daughters". Abraham answered the military's criticism with: "It seems like an attempt to not face reality", and called the reporting "rigorous". This desk found no Foreign Ministry statement as of September 13, 2026.

How it is spreading, and by whom. Three distinct streams carry the film. First, the film's own campaign: The Guardian as producer, festival press, and the directors' acceptance remarks ("It's our country that is doing these crimes"). Second, outlets that convert the testimony into a settled finding: RT ran "Israel used AI to kill thousands of Palestinians in Gaza – documentary"; Al Jazeera filed its coverage under "Crimes Against Humanity"; the activist site Daily Kos headlined "the Gaza genocide"; the conspiracy site The People's Voice ran "Insanely fun video game: Israeli soldiers describe slaughtering thousands". Third, the counter-stream, which dismisses the film wholesale as "blood libel" without engaging the testimony. A figure of "up to 70,000 human targets" circulates in the second stream; this desk could not trace it to a verifiable statement in the film and the only figure with a documented origin is the 37,000 of the 2024 investigation. Do not repeat 70,000 as a fact.

Assessment (Lions of Zion). Legitimate criticism is not propaganda because it is severe, and testimony from serving or former soldiers is a recognised form of journalism whose anonymity is normal. Two things are nevertheless true at once. The film cannot be checked by an outside reader: the sources are anonymous, the thresholds are recollected rather than shown in documents, and the film does not publish the orders it describes. And the IDF's denial is a blanket institutional statement that does not engage the specific thresholds or dates, and the same institution's own inquiries in 2025–2026 have acknowledged serious failures elsewhere. The resolution state is therefore disputed, not refuted and not verified. The claim that AI selected targets without human approval is contradicted by the IDF and, notably, not what the 2024 reporting said either: the sources then described humans approving machine-generated lists quickly, which is a claim about oversight, not about autonomy. The claim that civilian deaths were budgeted into strikes on homes is a claim about proportionality thresholds, which only documents or a judicial process can settle.

What a reader can do. Separate three propositions when this film is cited: that an AI-assisted database existed and shaped target lists (reported by multiple sources since 2024, characterised differently by the IDF); that permitted civilian-casualty thresholds were set and rose (asserted by anonymous testimony, denied as policy); that killing was intentional by design (the film's conclusion, not a documented finding). Ask which of the three a post is actually claiming, and whether it cites the film, the 2024 reporting, or nothing.

Still open / watch next. Whether any interviewee goes on the record; whether the directors publish documents; whether the Military Advocate General or a court addresses the thresholds; the film's Israeli release; whether a Foreign Ministry or government statement follows Bennett's; and how the 70,000 figure propagates.

Last checked: September 13, 2026.

Public sources

  1. Israeli-made Gaza documentary wins at Venice festival RTÉ (AFP/Reuters) · 12 Sept 2026
  2. IDF rejects testimonies in Israeli-made documentary about AI-powered killing in Gaza The Times of Israel · 11 Sept 2026
  3. Israelis' film alleging AI-assisted killing of Gaza civilians wins Venice jury prize The Times of Israel · 11 Sept 2026
  4. Israeli film on Gaza receives 25-minute ovation at Venice premiere Al Jazeera · 10 Sept 2026
  5. 'NAZA' Review: Doc Accuses Israel Of Using AI To Kill Gaza Civilians Deadline · 10 Sept 2026
  6. Former Israeli Prime Minister Takes Aim At Yuval Abraham And Rachel Szor's 'NAZA' Deadline · 10 Sept 2026
  7. Israel used AI to kill thousands of Palestinians in Gaza – documentary (propagator example, not a source of fact) RT · 10 Sept 2026
  8. Documentary alleging Israel committed wanton killing in Gaza gets standing ovation in Venice Jewish Telegraphic Agency · 9 Sept 2026
  9. 'NAZA' documentary premieres in Venice with Gaza war claims The Jerusalem Post · 9 Sept 2026
  10. 'NAZA' Venice Premiere: Gaza Documentary Earns Record Standing Ovation Variety · 9 Sept 2026
  11. Israeli film about killing of Gazan civilians gets 25-minute record ovation at Venice premiere The Times of Israel · 9 Sept 2026
  12. 'Lavender': The AI machine directing Israel's bombing spree in Gaza +972 Magazine · 2 Apr 2024

Known unknowns

Not established

  • Identities, ranks, units and service dates of the 24 interviewees
  • Whether the described collateral-damage thresholds were written policy, unit practice or recollection
  • The origin of the '70,000 targets' figure circulating online (the 2024 investigation reported 37,000)
  • Whether any document or order shown in the film can be authenticated
  • Whether the Military Advocate General has examined the specific allegations
  • Whether the film will be released in Israel
  • Illustration attached
Version history
  1. v2

    Attached a story-specific editorial illustration for the article and homepage surfaces, disclosed as an illustration and not as documentary evidence. The article text is unchanged.

Keep reading

All of Fake Resistance